Should have artificial donate remain to compensate for the tragedy of debt take the responsibility

In July of last year, the wife of good Guo Yu has owed the next medical cost of 530 thousand Yuan in 3 north medical courtyards since postpartum big bleeding is dead. This Henan comes to Beijing job hunter is unable to repay this cost. Not repay cost hospital disagree that he takes away the remain of wife. Hospital suggests him to donate the remain of wife to use , make medical dissect, this medical cost may be canceled once for all. Guo Yu feels very can not undertake the conscience of all the life if so being him debt. Half a year comes he only can do keep watch besides hospital mortuary frozen deceased wife. ( " the capital China of January 23 newspaper " reportHttp: / /news.sina.com.cn/s/2008-01-23/091814807777.shtml)

Say objectively, when Guo Yu is unable to repay the medical cost of 530 thousand Yuan very , again disagree on amortize condition take off, hospital puts forward to donate remain compensate for debt do not lose solve the method of problem for one: Remain donate to use make medical dissect can benefit future generations, may again alleviate the spiritual and economic pressure with very huge Guo Yu. But problem is no matter stem from what reason, as Guo Yu disagrees very that this one is suggested , what we have to respect him select - - even if his choice is to stem from ignorance, this is his right.

The notice of the author arrives , when about " the postpartum death of pregnant woman defaults medical care cost, hospital puts forward contribution remain to compensate for debt , do you agree with the practice of hospital? In " network investigation, the quilt of 81.79% searcher opposition this kind of practice, think that the practice of hospital is inhuman. This kinsfolk remain in the mind that explains current stage in general people are buried is install idea is still deep-rooted, and donating remain to compensate for debt have touched human dignity bottom line. Therefore, excoriate this one blindly to come to Beijing the idea of job hunter falls behind , really, call one 100 taste Chen Zas.

May if we for hospital consideration one takes off , will discover that hospital also compels in helplessness. Under at the moment medical system, hospital is not philanthropic organization, it will also subsist , and its survival is huge for the alive meaning of the masses: Hospital has gone bankrupt because of patient debt, not only loss of state assets, and directly causing people to have illness to have no place see , will harm the rights and interests of more person. Go bankrupt with state-owned enterprise to be killed biggest is as masses of worker, reason is understood easily. Moreover, under the condition that family members have not paid advance payment , hospital rescues patient actively, it is put forward just that knowing is not malice to be in arrears or the suggestions of contribution remain or payment by instalments have been enough humane.

Such analysis one takes off , problem has come: As patient family members and hospital have not been wrong , who should come to undertake responsibility for this tragedy? Human society is a collective, it can not be buried that a member dies to settle , does its kinsfolk suffer heavy economic, spiritual suffering and conscience condemnation therefore , must have artificial this to take the responsibility? From association of ideas not long ago, Xiao Zhi Jun that occurs in Beijing refuses the disturbance that the signature of surgical operation causes wife a corpse two lives to cause , as well as nation-wide every place again and again appearance despise illness to cannot afford the tragedy that medicine causes , the author thinks that is so because nobody therefore undertakes responsibility.

Report says that in preliminary statistical 2007, Chinese financial revenue exceeds the RMBs of 100 million more than 50 thousand, foreign exchange reserve exceeds at one 5000 billion U.S. dollar. Evidently along with economy development, the financial resources of our country already this non past than, we have ability completely to solve social member , the especially disadvantageous raw old ill dead problem of group - - this one takes us from human birth always Zi Zi so as beautiful ideal. However, why still appear again and again to despise illness carry , drag , as well as the human world that throws away tramp to deliver its death tragedy? This is the shame of human civilization. Citizen tax contributes to form government , do not fall into difficult condition about being expectation in individual time can get the help of collective?

Moreover, say that guarantee that every citizen is seemly dignity land alive is government department the duty that is duty-bound. Say normally, the tragedy of similar appearance should have artificial this to undertake responsibility - - or apology, or resign to apologize , everybody right duty advantage is distinct, society then can be harmonious to operate. May problem is , for years not only, having not heard of have the what lead who has been therefore asked duty. If the scheme of health care reform begins to brew from last year, hearing stairs solely sound , do not see person until this year have not also seen sound , is expert allegedly with department when fight scheme leading right, mutual not appearance let. Why do they ignore the rights and interests of taxpayer for self interests? I think , reason is nobody meeting for people die take the responsibility , and they do not exist to despise ill difficult problem. Therefore the author thinks , must should have artificial donate remain to compensate for the tragedy of debt take the responsibility , otherwise tragedy will not be stoped.