Xiao Liang today with city State Education Commission for book law court. In this year graduate student enters school examination in, since when the unofficial biography of examination hall sends answer person have been grabed current, it had been seized that bringing the electronic equipment of cheating enter Xiao Liang of examination hall, soon afterwards, had been expeled. May he claims to be have thrown battery before examination, have not taken over answer , and do not form to cheat , should not be expeled. American courtyard is considered , Xiao Liang and female friend violate electronic equipment rule tape enters examination hall, cooperating with him the site outsider that cheats Yuan have implemented to deliver the behavior of answer in examination hall, regardless of Xiao Liang whether receive answer, the behavior of it for cheating has set up. ( " the Beijing evening paper of November 14 "Http: / /news.sina.com.cn/c/l/2007-11-14/144414305836.shtml)
Though the author very repugnant examination cheats , may come for this matter to see , the author thinks the practice of school loses rash - - has not made clear Xiao Liang before whether have implemented to take over this answer fact , school has no right to expel Xiao Liang. Unless this school has following stipulation,: Only bring the equipment of cheating to enter examination hall , no matter Fou enforcement cheats , expel always. May be pleasant to the eye from news, this school has no this stipulation. The opinion of " regardless of Xiao Liang whether receive answer, it cheats behavior has set up " can not be set up. Beijing State Education Commission shows , expeling punish , have endured to hear certificate and complaint program , it is pawned invariably that city State Education Commission has made the decision that maintains punishment. This is sheer nonsense.
To prove the mistake of this conclusion, we need to lift a simple example. If a person wants to kill a person , he has asked assistant , also has good preparation kill a person weapon depository is on the body. In the process of killing a person , his partner has implemented to kill a person behavior. But he has regreted , does not want to have killed a person , and have not participated. It is just in now , policeman has grasped partner, partner has let him, policeman has discovered that he hides the weapon on the body. So, according to the logic of central American courtyard, this person also wants to have been tried in accordance with law just as. May in fact, court joint trial sentences this person?
Answer is self-evident. The basis of judicial adjudication is criminal fact, instead of motive. If estimate that this world has long had no person according to motive adjudication: Excuse me, on this world, who has no criminal motive? Have seen beauty, who has not implemented the motive raped? In front of put money when, who has no motive of corruption? Who has no motive of recreational activities using public funds? Have you no motive of the sight-seeing world of public expense? , , , I recognize , have these motive I have. May Public Security Bureau has not grabed me, court has not also tried me. Because motive is motive only , and has not endangered other person with society, I have not also profited from it.
School manages strictly for examination, maintain school discipline pure just, starting point is good, when at the moment campus cheats , plagiarize prevail big environment takes off , even say that is estimable. But we are now the societies of legal system, any punishment must according to laws and regulations, can not take for granted. Take this incident to see that the author thinks , correct practice asks neutral side, as the department of public security, through technical appraisement, making clear Xiao Liang to take over answer after all have no. Only this is made it clear that , implementing punishment just have basis. School is the place of imparting knowledge and educate people , book should first Chui Fan, handle affairs in accordance with law. May we see , many schools break the law openly , punish student at will , intrude student rights and interests. School has seemingly broken away from society , has become independent concession. So, the author suggests central American courtyard give birth to person person will soon go to mend legal knowledge.
没有评论:
发表评论